This is the third in my series of blogs on panels at Ravencon I’m NOT doing. For further explanation, see my earlier blog here.
WHERE DO YOU GET YOUR IDEAS FROM?
When people find out my mother is a professional art quilter, they almost always say, “Oh! My grandmother was a quilter!” And maybe they’ll follow that up with something about patchwork scraps or the like. Note that my mother uses computer-aided design, state-of-the-art quilting machines, laser-guidance, and all kinds of things your average grandmother-the-quilter would never bother using for a hand-stitched patchwork quilt (nor would my mother, for that matter; they’d be unnecessary). My mother usually gives some form of “smile and nod” type response, knowing there is no real comparison between what she does and that.
As a writer, there are certain things you hear all the time that the best response is a similar “smile and nod.” Among them are “Oh, I’d like to write a book some day. My memoirs would be fascinating!” (The people who live lives interesting enough to make good memoirs are often too busy living those lives to think about writing them) and “Oh, you wrote a book? Anything I might have read?” (How would we know? Usually, we don’t even know these people well enough to know whether they read at all, much less if they might possibly have read anything we wrote).
Another question we often have to deal with in the topic of this Ravencon panel: “Where do you get your ideas?” And often, as a writer, the answer is a smile, a nod, and some pithy nonsense answer. Sometimes we’ll expound on it, and yes, following whatever we suggest WILL (usually) give you some ideas.
But here’s the thing: If you’ve been writing for a while (like I have, and most writers who’ve published have), coming up with new ideas isn’t the problem. The problem is we have so many ideas that it’s impossible to get around to them all, and usually coming up with an answer to that question gives us even more.
Because ideas come from everywhere, and are in everything we do. Do you want to know where the ideas have come from for things I’ve written (published and not published)?
- I was in the sixth grade. Inspired by a character from the Danny Dunn books, I challenged some kids in my class to give me a word, any word, and I’d give them a story around it. The word they gave me was eyeballs. I gave them a story involving mutant eyeballs taking over the town. Sadly, like everything else I wrote in my school years, it was lost (at least the handwritten stuff, like this thing; the schools were supposed to keep permanent records of everything I wrote that would follow me from elementary to junior high to high school. Come high school, my file was “misplaced.” Shame, that — while none of it was usable at all, some of it might have been worth saving to re-visit some day).
- Back when I was in high school, I had a teacher that said “You cannot write from a 1st person omniscient perspective.” I suddenly felt challenged to write a story in the first person omniscient perspective whose main character was a mind reader. (This resulted in a short piece, almost flash, that I still plan to publish if I ever find somewhere for it… but it’s far too small to publish on its own, and I have nothing to group it with)
- I was in a college. I had been assigned to read Oedipus Rex for a class. This was the fourth or fifth time I was being required to read this “classic” piece of dreck. I heard for the first time, however (and I’ve never bothered to confirm it) that the three plays that are the current “Oedipus Trilogy” are actually the only three survivors of a set of NINE plays (3 interconnected trilogies). So, to try and get myself through reading the play again, I used it as research for a new prequel (perhaps explaining just why the gods entrapped Jocasta and Oedipus so horribly).
- A discussion about whether axes would really be a good weapon for stock-fantasy-race Dwarves, and if so why (and\or in what situations), and if not what really would be a good weapon for them. This contributed to In Treachery Forged (but was not the sole idea behind that story).
- Back before self-publishing became viable (or at least before I recognized the opportunity), I was trying to go for a traditional publishing deal. I used many tools to find possible places to submit my books and short stories, including a book (the Writer’s Marketplace) which listed what genres each publisher was looking for. There was one particular publisher which noted they mostly did non-fiction, but they did publish four novels each year “focusing on caves and spelunking.” I came up with an idea for a story of a fictional cave — whose layout and general location would be based on a composite of the three or four different caves I have been spelunking in — that had been involved in numerous incidents over the millennia (a prehistoric man’s home, a refuge during the civil war, a boy scout-esque educational trip, and more), the cave itself unchanging. Unfinished; as a compilation of short stories (I’m even slower in the short form than I am writing novels) it’s a slog. I haven’t given up on it, but it’s very low priority.
- I saw one too many anime and cartoons where characters existed who had hair over their eyes. I started wondering why someone would have that hairstyle. (Inspiration for Euleilla from In Treachery Forged)
- As I’ve said before, The Kitsune Stratagem came about because I ran into too many people who were saying “Elves and Dwarves are so overplayed! If I see another book with an elf in it I’m going to throw it across the room!” (and similar sentiments). I figured I’d see just how overplayed it came across if I tried a similar story to one I would have written using Elves and Dwarves and Dragons. but instead substituted in other types of fantastical creatures (in this case, Kitsune and Wulvers and Bunyips, oh my!)
- I was watching some long-forgotten TV show where there was a discussion of sawed-off shotguns. I started wondering what the fantasy equivalent would be. The resulting story will be appearing in the upcoming World’s Enough anthology, due to be published in time for a launch party at Balticon (May 26-29). Since I’m not the one who set that schedule, there’s a slim chance it’ll actually be released on time.
- Getting a bit silly, and instead of saying the phrase “he brought a knife to a gun fight” I replaced it with “he brought a trebuchet to a sword fight.” Something unfinished and put off for a while, but maybe I’ll get around to it some time.
- I wanted a non-stereotypical hero (think someone like Porkins in Star Wars) in a space-based science fiction novel. I wrote about half of it before I learned that my plot was almost identical to Night Train to Rigel. (Well, maybe it was Slow Train to Arcturus. I always mix those two up) I liked what I had, but I decided I needed to re-plot the whole thing, so it’s waiting for a while.
- I was watching a hockey game, and started wondering how hockey would be played in space. That was the origin of the Rink of War.
- While researching the California gold rush (for the Rink of War), I read the story of real-life character Emperor Norton. I thought about bringing someone like him into a sci-fi boom-town setting. The result (Emperor Norton II) makes a brief appearance in the Rink of War, but was a central figure in the sequels… of which four are mostly written, but since there was so little interest in the Rink of War itself I’ve abandoned that project. I may revisit it, some day, retooling the planned series of shorts (short stories, novelettes, and novellas) as a full length novel.
I could go on. And on. And on. My full idea bank of unwritten\unfinished stories (even just the ones I’ve made some effort to plot out or take notes on) would be ten, twenty, a hundred times that long. So, yeah. The idea that ideas are hard to come by seems… alien to me. Which might be why I didn’t sign up for this panel in the first place….
Edit: Comments closed because of multiple spam attempts.